WootBot


quality posts: 14 Private Messages WootBot

Staff

There are plenty of places on Woot where you can find helpful information. This is not one of those places. Every week we will be comparing 3 pairs of things that shouldn’t be compared using this formula: Unrelated Thing X vs. Unrelated Thing Y in terms of Function Z. Facts will be misunderstood, overlooked, or changed for the sake of the argument. Enjoy.

1. The Mayflower vs. Bird Seed in terms of Throwing The Craziest Party This Town’s Ever Seen

This really depends on what town you’re talking about. If it’s Plymouth, Pennsylvania, they’ve seen what kind of party the Mayflower can bring. On the other hand, Bodega Bay, California has already experienced the party that bird seed can inspire, which is a party with a lot of birds (and really, that’s a party they probably don’t want to throw again). What I’m getting at is “throwing the craziest party this town’s ever seen” is not a simple task. It requires much research into the town in question’s history in order for you, the thrower, to determine whether or not the local citizens have, in fact, seen such a crazy party.

Advantage:

It’s a toss up

 

2. Fumes vs. A Mix Tape in terms of A Dubious Omen

Fumes often indicate things that have already occurred – the pilot light on your stove went out, your car’s exhaust system has given up, you fed your dog the wrong thing, etc. – and therefore cannot be omens. A mix tape – and by “tape,” I’m talking about an actual cassette – is an indicator of something: that the person who made it is one of those hipsters who cares more about appearing cool and ironic than he does about sound quality. Which is to say, a mix tape is a very dubious omen, indeed. It foreshadows an inevitable and unpleasant revelation: that its maker is kind of a tool.

Advantage (if you can really call it an advantage):

A Mix Tape

 

3. Butter vs. A Paper Cutter in terms of Making a Young Lady’s Heart Flutter

The problem with a paper cutter is they make lots of clutter, and a young lady’s heart doesn’t flutter for clutter, unless she’s a nutter. No, butter from the udder is better to get her. Just mutter, “here’s some butter,” and be sure not stutter, and young lady’s heart will surely flutter as she will see that you plan to bake her a cookie (or three) and as we all know, cookies are the keys to wooing all the young ladies.

Advantage:

Butter

 

For last week's arguments, the Rebuttal of the Week goes to user dukeofwulf, who presents a simple yet flawless argument as to why a license trumps a canoe in terms of learning to tie your shoes:

Two points in favor of the Marriage License:
1. "Tying the knot" could serve as inspiration for learning to do it for realsies.
2. Having a spouse means what's yours is theirs. That means your shoes are actually their shoes. It's in your spouse's best interest to keep their shoes tied so you don't go around stepping on the laces and ripping the shoes up. They'll either teach you how to do it, or you'll see them do it enough times that you'll pick it up eventually.


Conclusion? Marriage License.

Sometimes the most complicated argument wins; other times the most concise argument wins. Why? Because Completely Unfair Comparisons is an equal opportunity blog feature! So go ahead: try to argue with one of the above 3 comparisons and see how you fare next week!

Photos: "Uncertainty" by flickr user, nicubunu.photo; Photo of tape by flickr user, supernative; "Melting butter" by flickr user, tarale. All used under a Creative Commons License.

dukeofwulf


quality posts: 5 Private Messages dukeofwulf

Why, thank you. I accept my win with the modesty and grace of Kanye West; that is to say, none at all.

Anyway, this week I beg to differ on item 3, Butter vs. A Paper Cutter in terms of Making a Young Lady’s Heart Flutter.

It's simple. The question as stated refers to youth. When I was a young man, oh, about 8 or so, I used scissors and folded paper to create quite lovely snowflakes and rows of people holding hands. I may not have been paying attention at the time, but I'm quite sure that the young ladies of my class had their hearts thoroughly fluttered by my paper cutting skills. And who could blame them?

To be sure, I've used butter to flutter women's hearts with tasty foods since then (I make a heck of a buttered toast), but since the question specified youth, I have to give this one to the paper cutter.

edit: er... first?

dcobranchi


quality posts: 0 Private Messages dcobranchi

I'd like to argue #1.

I've been to many crazy (wedding) parties where the guests threw bird seed at the bride and groom. Throwing the Mayflower at them would be crazy, but would surely be the end of the (wedding) party.

Advantage: Bird seed

abitterwoman


quality posts: 26 Private Messages abitterwoman

I am letting the suspense build before I try for a comeback. Also, my brain is fried from finals and I couldn't think of anything good.

Good luck all! And congrats to last weeks winner! Great job, Kanye!

"Computers don't make errors. What they do, they do on purpose."

moviewatcher


quality posts: 1 Private Messages moviewatcher

3. Butter vs. A Paper Cutter in terms of Making a Young Lady’s Heart Flutter

A paper cutter is very good at one thing. Cutting. Ignore the graphic warnings, bypass the "body intrusion" indicator on industrial paper cutters and very soon, you will have cut to the heart of the matter. And by matter, I mean the young lady you placed on the cutter. Not only is this messy, but the young lady's heart will have stopped instantly when cut through. No fluttering, just one quick cut and finis.

Butter will also kill your young lady, but it will take it's sweet, salty, rich, wonderfully tasting time about it. Use any recipe by Julia Child or Paula Deen, and in a few decades, your young lady's cholesterol laden heart will begin to flutter, stutter, and eventually stall. Sure, she's just as dead, but she'll have a far longer and more enjoyable life with you as the executive chef of her heart.

Advantage: Butter

TimDroz


quality posts: 0 Private Messages TimDroz

3. Butter vs. A Paper Cutter in terms of Making a Young Lady’s Heart Flutter

If someone (perhaps wearing a hockey mask) ripped the blade off a paper cutter and brandished it threateningly in the vicinity of a young lady, her heart would likely do more than flutter.

00000100


quality posts: 8 Private Messages 00000100

Moviewatcher beat me to it - despite the wonderful rhyme, I believe butter to be superior at making a young lady's heart flutter, as her corroded (not carotid) arteries will cause her heart to writhe in horrible anguish.

As an aside, all of the submissions this week are more morbid than usual.

Just sayin'.