I got three each of red, burnt orange, medium brown, khaki and cream with beige and black collar and sleeve trim. All are 100% preshrunk cotton by Gildan and quite comfortable.
Overall I am happy, as I got more than five shirts for the price of about three. If I'd gotten other colors as well, I might be even happier (but then all of these colors are usable and who knows what else I might have gotten.)
Also, I got an email informing me that I'd be credited the sales tax (I am in NY City), so the deal has gotten even sweeter.