Oh...milkshake flavor. In that case, make mine a chocolate malt. Extra thick please. (Milkshake, not the center sock)

Whatever brings all the boys to the yard.

Chocolate Malt

I chose other. I add malt powder to my milkshakes, and Chocolate seems to be the best match. Without malt, strawberry wins.

For milkshakes: Vanilla -- made with chocolate ice cream.

Jamocha.

Oreo shake. Simple as that. No trumping it.

Peanut butter!

PB or Chocolate PB

Best I ever had was a peach shake in N.C.

chocolate malt

Chocolate Malt Mocha

Either cookie dough or caramel!!!!

fishshapedethylbenzene wrote:Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana...Malt.

AGREED. This.

Now that the poll has been fixed, I vote Oreo.

Butterscotch, enough said.

Rootbeer

peppermint

Banana all the way!

Chocolate mother-funking banana.

Peach (at Chick-fil-A)

Chocolate MALT Milk Shake.

Chocolate MALT Milk Shake.

Maybe I'd have to Ketchup, but you asked me to comment on (other) and switched to...?
First choice, no sox in my shakes. (Although I have shaken in my sox) Shaken, not stir... yeah, Ok, I've stirred too. Back to first choice, it would have been a MALT... w/extra malt powder! Then... Flavours? Chocolate AND Banana. Both were choices, but not both selectable (together)
(Sigh...)
Hey... you asked!

Cookies & Cream

Well I am glad the poll was sorted out because that original question was weird. I voted chocolate because chocolate is just great even not knowing the question. Chocolate shakes are for dipping your fries in...

I like a lot of chocolate in my shakes, so I'm going with box of chocolate. Life is like a Box Of Chocolates, you never know what you're going to get.

A good chocolate malt, made w vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup & powdered (not liquid) malt.
Mmmm-MMMM

Huckleberry

SO GOOD.

Chocolate malts are my favorite.

Black and white! (Vanilla ice cream with chocolate syrup)

Cookies and Cream is the bestest!

Eggnog or shamrock

There IS no bad flavor...bacon, unicorn...but not fish...uh uh

Your sister's... of course. It brings all the boys to the yard.

peanut butter

bacon of course.

Chocolate, first, because it's the classic shake, especially with malt.

But then for something more cooling, I'll take the mint chip.

And now something sweeter, caramel is nice.

A fruit flavor is always part of the list, and it has to be huckleberry, unless for dessert some sweet fruit, that's pineapple.

What's that? I can have only one? OK, chocolate, with malt, will be grand.

Mocha es the besttt!

Capt. Crunch from SCREME in NY - FTW!!