La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Cream Cleanser

I've used Cetaphil cleanser for years and have been happy with it overall, with the exception that it is not good at removing eye makeup. I decided to give this cleanser a try because of the positive reviews and several mentions of it being good at removing eye makeup. I am a little disappointed with this product. The positives: it cleanses well, removes MOST of my eye makeup, very little product is needed (maybe 1/4 tsp) to cleanse my entire face so the tube will last a very long time, and no detectable fragrance. However, there are downsides for me. Although it removes most of my eye makeup, it doesn't remove all of it. It also slightly stings my eyes even after rinsing thoroughly. I also have noticed my face reacts to it and breaks out into a mild rash after using, so I don't think it's a mild cleanser. I also don't like how my face feels after I wash with this product. It feels stripped and tight. I am going back to Cetaphil and will find some other way to get my eye makeup off.