Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

Ok, hear me out. I have always, always (I'm 44) worn the most waterproof mascara you can find. I need it to be sweat proofand cry proof🙃, among my top requirements. I have started noticing over the past few years (no matter what I try) that I get "smudgy" marks under my eyes throughout the day. And we're not talking the sultry, racoon smudges, were talking blotches and circles. I can't stand it. I even stopped wearing mascara on my lower lashes to try and curb this to no avail. After doing a ton of research this product came up as one of the top recommendations. I had to try it. Results: it works (somewhat-ish?). As stated I like very very very waterproof mascara and although I would take the plunge being so desperate, but this is not for me. However, I can do a light sweep on my bottom lashes without hardly any smudging throughout the day. If you are looking for a lightweight, clean mascara this is for you. It does not wear off onto your skin for the most part, however it will rub off at the slightest touch. I feel that once it sets, you almost cannot tell you have any mascara on. I like a little bit more of a glamour-ish look to my mascara and this is definitely not that. If you are looking for clean, natural looking (no makeup look) lashes this is for you.