Maybelline Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara
$5.99
$9.98
40% off
Reference Price
Condition: New
Top positive review
29 people found this helpful
I love it!!
By Madam Anastazja on Reviewed in the United States on April 21, 2025
Okay, so I never write reviews, but this mascara deserves a love letter. I’ve been on a borderline desperate mission to find a mascara that doesn’t make my eyes feel like I just stared into a wind tunnel full of dust. Most mascaras I’ve tried lately either flake, smudge, or make my eyes burn like I just chopped onions with my eyelids. My lashes are naturally long but need color to show up, and this mascara does exactly that. It’s easy to apply, builds beautifully, and separates every lash like a pro. No clumps. No crunchy mess. Just bold, fluttery lashes that actually last. Now here’s the part where I was SHOOKETH. I paired it with a lash curler (first time ever) and… WOW. The difference was unreal. Like, I’ve paid for lash lifts and tints before, but after this combo? I’m never going back to chemical lash treatments again. This look is PERFECTION. And my personal bonus? No irritation. My eyes are dry and I use drops constantly, like 5-10 times a day. Let me tell you - this mascara doesn’t flinch. No smudging. No running. No raccoon vibes. Even on nights I was too tired to take it off, I woke up with perfect lashes. Not a single flake in sight. Also, I bought the Maybelline Sky High Glitter Mascara in Diamond Effect and when I layer it on top - game changer. A subtle shimmer that’s easily buildable for a big pop. I wish I had taken pictures to show off both as well as before and after as words simply do not do it any justice. Some may find this a con, but this is not a volumizing mascara. This mascara is all about length, lift, and definition, not va-va-voom volume. Personally, I don’t mind that at all. I prefer a fluttery, natural-but-enhanced lash, and this delivers exactly that for me. If you’re after big, bold volume, you might want to layer it with a volumizing primer or try a different mascara. Overall, I. AM. IN. LOVE. 10/10
Top critical review
Not for me
By Nicolle Lukezic on Reviewed in the United States on July 4, 2025
have very oily skin and hooded eyelids, so I rely on tubing mascaras to prevent raccoon eyes. I grabbed the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof hoping for tubing performance, but it doesn’t live up to that. Instead of forming clean “tubes” around each lash, it just clumps and flakes. Maybelline doesn’t clearly advertise it as a tubing formula, but if that’s what you expect, you’ll be let down. It smudges under my eyes by midday and leaves flaky bits on my cheeks. For a similar price, I much prefer No.7 Stay Perfect Mascara—it actually tube without flaking. But no.7 has been irritating my eyes so I wouldn’t necessarily recommend that one either Overall, I wouldn’t repurchase this one. There are better, truly tubing mascaras out there that hold up on oily, hooded eyes.
Sort by:
Filter by:
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews